by Karen Yvonne Hamilton, 2024


Eugene Joseph Hamilton was the son of Eugene Joseph ‘King Gene’ HAMILTON (1883-1966) and Rebecca Elizabeth JOHNSON (1887-1947).

Known as Josie, his father’s name appears alongside his own often enough that the nickname helps distinguish them.

BIRTH

NOTE: Records show varying birth dates: WWII Draft lists November 28, 1911, Social Security documentation lists November 28, 1912, in Key West, Florida, while the 1930 Federal Census recorded an approximate birth year of 1913 when Joseph was enumerated at age 17 in Spring Hill, Monroe County, living with his parents and siblings.

SIBLINGS


CHILDREN

  • Harvey Hamilton 1932–unknown
  • Eugene Joseph Hamilton Jr. 1933–1996
  • Maybelle Hamilton 1934–1998
  • Irene Hamilton 1938–unknown
  • Jerry Wade Hamilton 1949–2021
  • Mark Thomas Hamilton


Josie, Isabel, and their children


He lived with his parents and siblings in Flamingo, FL in 1920.

1920 United States Federal Census

In 1930, he lived with his parents at Poinciana Point in the Everglades and worked as a Fisherman. Their family is also listed on the 1930 Key West census as living at 1415 Pearl St. Key West, FL.

The two federal census schedules place the family in different parts of Monroe County in 1930. At Poinciana Point, Joseph was listed as seventeen and already working in the commercial fishery. His father and several nearby Hamiltons were also recorded as fishermen. The Key West schedule put Joseph in his parents’ household at 1415 Pearl Street, gave his age as eighteen, and listed no occupation for him. The schedules document the family in both places that year. They leave the timing and circumstances of their stays open.

1930 United States Federal Census – Key West
1930 United States Federal Census – Everglades

In 1940, Josie was living with his wife, Belle, and children (Eugene, Maybelle, Irene, and Harvey) in Flamingo where he worked as a fisherman.

1940 United States Federal Census

Josie was well liked by all in the islands. He was deaf and did not speak. He is remembered as being an extraordinary builder and is said to have built homes and boats from salvaged materials.

From Lostmans Heritage: Pioneers in the Florida Everglades, “ The families had occasional run-ins with the bad boys of the islands. William Rewis and his cohorts were well known in the region for their criminal activities and violent tendencies. In 1929, Sheriff Niles from Key West and his guide, Salvador Gomez, were lost for a few days in the islands after searching for the Rewis gang. Rewis was accused of stabbing Gene Hamilton in several places and slashing the throat of Gene’s son, Josie, the deaf-mute, while they were all at a dance on Lostmans River. Rewis also allegedly hit Rebecca Hamilton over the head with a boat hook and bit “a piece of her nose off” and assaulted her daughter, Irene.”


The Shooting at Turkey Key

The Key West Citizen, August and September 1931, clippings in the supplied Josie Hamilton Newspaper.pdf, pp. 1–4. The compilation includes an August 25 recovery report and a September 17 trial report. The early coverage refers to the accused man as Ford, while the September report uses Bodiford.

In August 1931, Josie and his sister were among a boating party that stopped at Turkey Key in the Ten Thousand Islands. Josie was deaf and did not speak. In its early coverage, The Key West Citizen reported that he could read lips, and John Bodiford’s account described the two men communicating by signs. The early report said the party stopped for gasoline and described a dispute over tobacco. Bodiford said Josie struck him before he fired. At trial, prosecution witnesses gave a different account of what set off the confrontation. They said Bodiford had made an improper proposal to Josie’s sweetheart before the party came to his houseboat.

Aug 22 1931 The Key West Citizen

“On Turkey Key one night in August 1931, Josie Hamilton stopped by John Bodiford’s houseboat to ask if he had any gas. Now, Bodiford supposedly was sweet on Josie’s girl and had made some improper advances towards her. So, when Josie and his people showed up at his home, he figured Josie’s girl had told on him. He ordered Josie and the others off his boat. Then he went to get his knife. His nephew, Charles, fearing trouble, jumped Josie and the fight was on. John Bodiford appeared with a gun and fired a shot that struck Josie’s sister, Helen, in the hand. The bullet tore straight through her hand and buried itself in Josie’s belly.  The trial, with John Bodiford charged with attempt to murder and Charles Bodiford charged as an accessory, went on throughout the fall.”

Aug 25 1931 The Key West Citizen

The accounts agree that Bodiford fired and that one bullet wounded both Josie and his sister as she tried to pull him away. The newspaper called her Helen. She may have been his sister Ellen, who appears with him in both 1930 census schedules. Josie was taken to Jackson Memorial Hospital in Miami in critical condition. By August 25, the Citizen reported that his father had wired Sheriff Niles with word that the doctors considered Josie out of danger. On September 17, the newspaper reported that the case against John and Charles Bodiford had gone to the jury. The supplied clippings end before a verdict.

“ The Key West Citizen reported that “Young Hamilton (Josie) is well known to a number of Key West people having lived here for several months with his parents, who came here to attend a trial, following several attempts on the life of the father (King Gene). They stayed here until conditions became more settled in that section (Lostman River).”

Sept 17 1931 The Key West Citizen

Josie’s Draft Card

U.S. WWII Draft Cards Young Men, 1940-1947 (front of card)
U.S. WWII Draft Cards Young Men, 1940-1947 (back of card)

DEATH

Josie Hamilton died on February 26, 1991, in Fort Myers, Florida, at the age of 77.

News-Press Fort Myers, Florida Thursday, February 28, 1991

This newspaper article was found on Ancestry .com, posted by Iris Williams. It seems to be missing a page. I am trying to locate the article online to fill in the blanks.

A later account of the Bocilla Preserve describes a small wood-frame house where a man named Josie Hamilton lived in the 1960s. That account credits the building to an earlier owner, Dixie Beggs.


1982 article transcribed

May 26, 1982 edition of the Pine Island Eagle, transcribed text of the feature article about Joseph “Josie” Hamilton, written by Maryellen F. Williams.

Josie Hamilton: He made his own way despite handicap

By Maryellen F. Williams

Joseph Hamilton, better known to his friends as “Josie,” is a Commercial Fisherman with a unique story. He is a proud man who has spent a lifetime providing for a family of six children and a wife, which granted, many men have done. So what makes him unique you ask? Josie Hamilton is a deaf-mute and has been all his life.

When he was a year old and living on North Lostmans River, now known as Everglades National Park, he contracted an ear infection which ultimately ruptured both ear drums leaving him permanently deaf for life. As his father knew no other way of life to teach his son, deaf or not, Josie was taught to fish and work the family Sugar Cane farm.

For the benefit of the novice let me stop here to explain what this meant. Most commercial fishermen use their ears to catch fish. They sit, deathly quiet, in a boat and listen for the fish making noise in the water. Eyesight is important but only as a secondary advantage as most fishermen fish at night.

Since Josie could hear with no ears, he developed his own method. He would put an oar in the water and “feel” the vibrations of the fish moving. He had to learn to judge the amount of fish by the strength of these vibrations. An error in judgement could mean hand poling (there were no gasoline engines) all his net overboard only to pick it back up to find one or two fish instead of a couple hundred pounds. But Josie learned.

As the nearest Deaf and Blind School was 400 miles away, and Josie was needed to work at home, he never learned to read or write. He did however learn to figure out of necessity, so when he settled his pay with the fish companies he would not get taken. To this day he can add a column of figures in his head as fast as most people figure on a calculator.

Learning to communicate his wants and needs was another problem. With no formal education in sign language… (Note: The article text cuts off at the bottom of this column page)

Page missing

in one piece all his life this would have been a little easier, but he didn’t. As most good commercial fishermen do, Josie moved with the fish.

In 1930 at the age of 17 he met and married his lifetime mate, Belle Rodriguez of Boca Grande. Josie built his own dirt floor Shantee where he and his bride took up residence on Lostmans River. Then Belle became pregnant and Josie decided it was time to move to Key West as fishing was more profitable. This was to be the first of many moves.

While in Key West his first son was born, Eugene. They lived there two years but times were hard with the depression driving the price of Mullet down to one cent a pound. So, the family moved back to Lostmans River. After a short stay there, they decided to try fishing further north. So Josie built a houseboat to live on and he again moved his family. This time to Cayo Costa.

By now the family had grown. There were now two daughters, Maybelle and Irene and another son Harvey. As three of the four children were of school age, Josie insisted they get an education that he never could. So each day they went to school by boat on Pointe Blanca Island. Josie sold the houseboat and bought a wooden house on Cayo Costa for his family. The oldest son, Eugene, would fish for his father at night and attend school during the day.

By eighth grade the schedule had become too grueling so Eugene was made to quit and work at fishing full time to help support the family. With the added income, Josie was able to buy a piece of land and build a house on Jug Creek. And so the family moved yet another time. While living on Jug Creek, his last two sons were born, Tommy and Jerry.

Harvey, like Eugene, went to work fishing and finally the family was able to purchase a piece of land on the mainland in Bokeelia. This time they moved the entire house, taking it apart board by board, nail by nail, and rebuilding it. That same house still stands today in Bokeelia.

Today, at 69, Josie Hamilton still lives and fishes in Bokeelia. He is highly respected by all the fishermen, young and old, as one of the old timers that made it. All six children got an education and married well.

Three of his four sons are commercial fishermen. Eugene branching off as a Dolphin Catcher, Harvey us President of O.F.F. (Organized Fisherman of Florida) and Tommy who works on a commercial boat in the keys. His two grandsons, Eugene’s boys, are both fishermen in Key Largo.

Yes, Josie Hamilton is a legend in his own time. He overcame the insurmountable odds of being a deaf mute, in a time and place where many individuals would have given up. He gained the respect of people everywhere he went. He worked hard and never said die. Today, he owns his own home where he keeps a small garden, owns his own boat with an engine, and yes, each day, weather permitting he still fishes.

A unique man, with a unique story and a respected m— (Text cuts off at the bottom of the column)


SOURCES

ANCESTRY WORKSHEET last updated November 8, 2026 by Karen Yvonne Hamilton

BIOGRAPHY LINK: https://exploringfloridahistory.org/2024/12/16/eugene-joseph-josie-hamilton/

     Supporting Document
Eugene Joseph “Josie” HAMILTON     
Father: Eugene Joseph ‘King Gene’ HAMILTON (1883-1966)U.S. WWII Draft Cards Young Men, 1940-1947; U.S., Social Security Applications and Claims Index, 1936-2007; various census records; oral family history
Mother: Rebecca Elizabeth JOHNSON (1887-1947)Social Security Applications and Claims Index, 1936-2007; various census records; oral family history
Birth Date: November 28, 1911 or 1912U.S. WWII Draft Cards Young Men, 1940-1947; U.S., Social Security Applications and Claims Index, 1936-2007
Birth Location: Key West, Florida  U.S. WWII Draft Cards Young Men, 1940-1947; U.S., Social Security Applications and Claims Index, 1936-2007
MARRIAGE: Isabelle Julian “Bella” Darna 1913–1981Florida, County Marriage Records, 1823-1982 (Listed as Isabell Rodriguez)
Marriage Date: 6 Nov 1931 Florida, County Marriage Records, 1823-1982
CHILDREN: Harvey Hamilton 1932–unknown; Eugene Joseph Hamilton Jr. 1933–1996; Maybelle Hamilton 1934–1998; Irene Hamilton 1938–unknown; Jerry Wade Hamilton 1949–2021; Mark Thomas HamiltonOBIT News-Press Fort Myers, Florida Thursday, February 28, 1991
RESIDENCES
1920 Flamingo, Florida1920 United States Federal Census
1930 Poinciana Point in the Everglades1930 United States Federal Census
1930 1415 Pearl St. Key West, Florida1930 United States Federal Census
1940 Flamingo, Florida1940 United States Federal Census
1991 Bokeelia, Lee County, FloridaOBIT News-Press Fort Myers, Florida Thursday, February 28, 1991; Bocilla Preserve site account, filed in the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service public docket.
DEATH Date: February 26, 1991OBIT News-Press Fort Myers, Florida Thursday, February 28, 1991
DEATH Location:  Cape Coral, Fort Myers, FloridaOBIT News-Press Fort Myers, Florida Thursday, February 28, 1991
BURIAL: Coral Ridge CemeteryOBIT News-Press Fort Myers, Florida Thursday, February 28, 1991

=======================================================================================

FLORIDA KEYS HISTORY FACEBOOK GROUP: Consider joining our group for more on Florida Keys History.

FLORIDA EVERGLADES HISTORY FACEBOOK GROUP: Consider joining our group for more on Florida Everglades History.