by Karen Yvonne Hamilton, 2024
By the summer of 1860, Hannah Knowles lived on Cudjoe Key in a small community whose census entries carried the same birthplace again and again: the Bahama Islands. Her husband was a mariner. Their son James had taken up the same occupation, and their daughter Sophia worked as a seamstress. Nearby lived their married daughter Sarah and her own young family. Across the water from the islands of Hannah’s birth, the Knowles family had become part of another island community.
The surviving records offer only glimpses of Hannah herself. Yet those glimpses, read alongside the history preserved by her descendants, trace a life connecting the Bahamas and the Florida Keys through marriage, migration, work, and the care of children.
Hannah Elizabeth PRANCE was born on October 20, 1814, in Long Island, Bahamas, to John William PRANCE (1780-1837) and Sarah Elizabeth last name unknown (1787-1837).
One surviving document opens a difficult part of the Prance family’s history. A registration return for January 1, 1822, identifies John William Prance, a shopkeeper on New Providence, as the enslaver of two people: Will, a sixty-year-old man, and Flora, a fifty-year-old woman. Both were recorded as Black and African. Prance swore to the return in Nassau on January 27.
The family biography associates this man with Hannah’s father, although the register itself does not establish that relationship. It also does not show whether Hannah lived with Will and Flora or knew them personally. What it does preserve is evidence of two human lives held in slavery by a man bearing her reported father’s name. Their names belong in this history alongside his.

MARRIAGE
Hannah married John Thomas KNOWLES on January 16, 1836 in Nassau, Bahamas. They had six children in 29 years: Sarah Ann, James Alexander, Sophia Lavinia, Oscar Washington, Justin Everett, and George Washington.
Current research attributes the marriage to St. Matthew’s Church and a newspaper reference, while noting that the original supporting documentation has not yet been secured. The marriage began the family story later visible in the Florida census records.


By 1850, John and Hannah were living in Key West. Their household included Sarah, James, Sophia, Oscar W., and a younger boy whose name appears as Chester on the supplied census image. ‘Chester’ is possibly a misspelling of Justin Everett.

John’s occupation was mariner. Hannah’s occupation column was blank. The document names the children and records their ages, but it tells us nothing of how she managed their days, what resources she had, or what the move from the Bahamas had meant to her. No account of the crossing accompanies these records. By the time the census taker reached them, however, the family had established a home in Key West.
NOTE ON CUDJOE KEY:
Originally called Littleton Island in 1772, some say that Cudjoe Key was named for the Joewood tree (also called cudjoewood). The more interesting story of how the key received its name is that it was named after an escaped slave named Cudjoe (a common African name) who lived on the key for some time. Local resident historian John Vieles believes that Cudjoe lived on the key before the island was surveyed in 1849. Whichever the case, the name Cudjoe’s Key later dropped the possessive and became simply Cudjoe Key.

Ten years later, the setting had changed. On August 18, 1860, the census enumerator recorded the Knowles household in the settlement of Cudjoe’s Key. John again appeared as a mariner, and Hannah was listed as a housekeeper. James, twenty-one, was also a mariner. Sophia, seventeen, was a seamstress. Washington, fifteen, and Justin, twelve, completed the household.
Those few entries show the children growing into working lives. James followed his father’s occupation at sea, while Sophia contributed a skill of her own. The census gives no earnings for either, but it makes their work visible.
John Thomas and Hannah’s daughter, Sarah Ann, had formed her own household nearby with Robert Johnson, another mariner, and their daughters Adela and Rebecca. Records show that Sarah KNOWLES Johnson immigrated to the U.S in 1852. In 1880 and 1885 she was living at 440 Angela St (St. Angella St) in Key West with two of her children, Joseph, a cigarmaker, and Velena.
The proximity matters: Hannah’s family now extended beyond the children under her roof. On the same census page, George Johnson’s household added another Bahamian-born family to the settlement. The record places the Knowleses within a community connected by shared origins as well as neighboring homes.

There was also a young mariner named James LONGRIDGE living on the island and a 33-year old sailmaker from North Carolina named Daniel MILLER lived nearby as the lone resident of Sugarloaf Key.
DEATH
Hannah PRANCE Knowles died on May 27, 1866, in Key West, Florida, at the age of 51, 20 days after giving birth to George. Family lore tells that infant George was adopted and raised by Hannah’s son, Justin and his wife, Jane Ann HOPKINS. Jane Ann duly recorded the birth of George Washington in her mother’s (Frances HARRARD Hopkins) bible, which she had inherited after her parents died on the same day, possibly from yellow fever as there was an epidemic that year (1865).
If that account is borne out, Hannah’s youngest child grew up in the household of one of her older sons. It would be a poignant continuation of the family life visible on Cudjoe Key: children becoming adults, establishing homes, and assuming responsibility for another generation.

Learn more about Yellow Fever (Yellow Jack or the Yellow Plague) in Florida.


Later, in 1870, Hannah’s husband, John Thomas, moved to No Name Key.

Hannah left no letters or personal testimony among the materials gathered here. Her surviving story rests in household lists, the occupations of her husband and children, the presence of a married daughter nearby, and the memories her descendants preserved. These fragments cannot recover her voice. They can restore her place in the family’s history: a Bahamian woman whose life crossed into the Florida Keys, where her children made homes of their own.
NOTE: Any additional info or photos would be appreciated.
Source and research note
Prepared from the 1822 New Providence enslaved-person registration return for John William Prance; and the 1850 and 1860 United States census images.
The exact birth date and place, parentage, marriage details, death date and circumstances, George’s maternity, and the account of his upbringing require additional original documentation. No cause of Hannah’s death is established by these materials.
SOURCES:
Ancestry.com; United States Federal Census Records; Hopkins family bible; family stories
ANCESTRY WORKSHEET last updated October 17, 2026 by Karen Yvonne Hamilton
BIOGRAPHY LINK: https://exploringfloridahistory.org/2024/12/20/hannah-elizabeth-prance/
| Supporting Document | |
| Hannah Elizabeth PRANCE | |
| Father: John William PRANCE (1780-1837) | No records found as of 2026. Family history lore. |
| Mother: Sarah Elizabeth last name unknown (1787-1837) | No records found as of 2026. Family history lore. |
| Birth Date: October 20, 1814 | 1850 and 1860 United States Federal Census |
| Birth Location: Long Island, Bahamas | 1850 and 1860 United States Federal Census |
| MARRIAGE: John Thomas KNOWLES | Bahama Gazette NO SOURCE DOCUMENTATION, found on Ancestry .com; 1850 and 1860 United States Federal Census; State of Florida Vital Statistics Death Certificate for Sarah Ann Johnson |
| Marriage Date: January 16, 1836 in Nassau, Bahamas | St Matthews Church Nassau Bahamas. Bahama Gazette NO SOURCE DOCUMENTATION, found on Ancestry .com |
| CHILDREN: Sarah Ann, James Alexander, Sophia Lavinia, Oscar Washington, Justin Everett, and George Washington | 1850 and 1860 United States Federal Census; State of Florida Vital Statistics Death Certificate for Sarah Ann Johnson |
| RESIDENCES | |
| (1850) Key West, Monroe, Florida | 1850 United States Federal Census |
| (1860) Cudjoe Key, Florida | 1860 United States Federal Census |
| Death Date: May 27, 1866 | No records found as of 2026. Family history lore. |
| Death Location: Key West, Monroe, Florida | No records found as of 2026. Family history lore. |
| Burial: Key West, Monroe, Florida | No records found as of 2026. Family history lore. |
=======================================================================================
FLORIDA KEYS HISTORY FACEBOOK GROUP: Consider joining our group for more on Florida Keys History.
FLORIDA EVERGLADES HISTORY FACEBOOK GROUP: Consider joining our group for more on Florida Everglades History.
Read more biographies of the Knowles and Prance family: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0HGYLGHMV

