Karen Yvonne Hamilton, 2025
Robert Joseph HAMILTON was born on November 6, 1910, in Chokoloskee, Florida, to John Leon HAMILTON (1885-1964) and Sarah Elizabeth JOHNSON (1889-1963).

SIBLINGS
- Mary Frances was born on January 14, 1906, in Florida.
- Eva Margaret was born on December 10, 1909, in Key West, Florida.
- Henry Gilbert was born on October 15, 1915.
- Adeline Agnes was born in 1915.
- Elizabeth Ann”Lizzie” was born on June 25, 1917, in Collier, Florida.
- Raymond was born in 1930.
MARRIAGE
Robert married Lola Lee CARRAWAY on January 6, 1926, in Tallahassee, Florida. Lola Lee was born in Wakulla County in 1911 to Laborn Maxwell “Buster” Carraway and Lular Eva Brooks Carraway. Lola Lee was previously married to Edwin Bryant Smith, 7 April 1931, in Franklin County, Florida. Family lore says that Lola Lee was found by police dead in an alley, year unknown.

CHILDREN
Lula May HAMILTON was born on January 15, 1927, in Wakulla, Florida.

In April of 1930, Robert sailed with Joaquin (King) Gomes aboard the USS Gov Cobb from Havana, Cuba to Key West, Florida.

In June 1930, Robert lived with his parents and siblings (line 24-29) on Lostmans River in the Florida Everglades. His grandfather, Richard (Robert) Hamilton and uncles lived nearby.

DEATH
Robert disappeared in the Everglades islands in February 1932 with his cousin, William ‘Buddy’ HAMILTON. Their bodies were never found, and they were presumed murdered. Robert was 21 years old.


Tampa Bay Times St. Petersburg Times St. Petersburg, Florida · Monday, February 01, 1932
A Biography found on FindAGrave.com
“Robert was the son of John Leon Hamilton and Sarah Elizabeth Johnson Hamilton.
Robert married Lola Lee Carraway January 6, 1926 in Leon County Florida. They lived with Lola Lee’s parents in Wakulla County for several months following the marriage. After about five months they went to Robert’s home in the Everglades. Lola Lee returned to Wakulla County alone and was pregnant with their child. Robert returned to Wakulla County and stayed with Lola Lee, at her parent’s home, until after the baby was born. Their daughter, Lula Mae Hamilton, was born January 15, 1927. Shortly after she was born Robert returned home to the Everglades without his family.
January 15, 1932 Robert died in the Everglades along with his cousin William M. Hamilton. Their boat was found but the boys were never found. His Uncle Eugene Hamilton believes his son William and nephew Robert Hamilton were murdered by a ‘mob’ in the Monroe County Fish War.
This is based on a letter written by Lola Lee to her mother in about 1935…the letter is titled “Just a Short Story of my Life”. Robert’s birth date and place of birth from the Florida Passenger Lists, 1898-1963 for Robert Hamilton. Traveling on the same ship with Robert was Joaquin Gomez; born 1 Mar 1901 in Carlos, FL. Information about Robert and William received from Iris Williams, relative of the two boys. Now find clippings from newspapers.com that verifies death.”
Presumed Dead
Neither Robert nor his cousin, William ‘Buddy’ Hamilton were ever found. William was officially declared deceased in 1949. Newspaper reports tell the story of the missing boys and the hunt for them, but no source has ever verified that the boys bodies were found.
SOURCES
1930 United States Federal Census; Florida, U.S., County Marriage Records, 1823-1982; Global, Find A Grave Index for Burials at Sea and other Select Burial Locations 1300s-Current; Florida, U.S., Arriving and Departing Passenger and Crew Lists 1930; Ancestry.com profile of Iris Williams.
Newspaper Sources about the disappearances
- Tampa Bay Times St. Petersburg Times St. Petersburg, Florida · Monday, February 01, 1932
- Orlando Evening Star Evening Reporter-Star Orlando, Florida · Tuesday, February 02, 1932
- The Tampa Tribune Tampa Morning Tribune Tampa, Florida · Tuesday, February 02, 1932
- Tampa Bay Times St. Petersburg Times St. Petersburg, Florida · Tuesday, February 02, 1932
- The St. Augustine Evening Record Saint Augustine, Florida · Tuesday, February 02, 1932
ANCESTRY WORKSHEET last updated November 8, 2026 by Karen Yvonne Hamilton
BIOGRAPHY LINK: https://exploringfloridahistory.org/2025/09/16/robert-joseph-hamilton/
| Supporting Document | |
| Robert Joseph Hamilton | |
| FATHER: John Leon HAMILTON (1885-1964) | 1930 United States Federal Census; family lore |
| MOTHER: Sarah Elizabeth JOHNSON (1889-1963) | 1930 United States Federal Census; family lore |
| Birth Date: November 6, 1910 | U.S., Arriving and Departing Passenger and Crew Lists, 1898-1963 A3618 – Arriving At Key West, Florida, 1907 – 1949 |
| Birth Location: Chokoloskee, Florida | U.S., Arriving and Departing Passenger and Crew Lists, 1898-1963 A3618 – Arriving At Key West, Florida, 1907 – 1949 |
| MARRIAGE: Lola Lee CARRAWAY on | Florida, County Marriage Records, 1823-1982; family lore; https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/137143053/robert_joseph-hamilton |
| Marriage Date: January 6, 1926, in Tallahassee, Florida | Florida, County Marriage Records, 1823-1982; family lore; https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/137143053/robert_joseph-hamilton |
| CHILDREN: Lula May HAMILTON was born on January 15, 1927, in Wakulla, Florida | Family lore; https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/137143053/robert_joseph-hamilton |
| RESIDENCES | |
| (1910) Chokoloskee, Florida | U.S., Arriving and Departing Passenger and Crew Lists, 1898-1963 A3618 – Arriving At Key West, Florida, 1907 – 1949 |
| (1930) Lostmans River in the Florida Everglades | 1930 United States Federal Census |
| (1930) Key West, Florida | U.S., Arriving and Departing Passenger and Crew Lists, 1898-1963 A3618 – Arriving At Key West, Florida, 1907 – 1949 |
| DEATH Date: abt February 1932 (disappeared, assumed dead) | Tampa Bay Times St. Petersburg Times St. Petersburg, Florida · Monday, February 01, 1932 |
| DEATH Location: Lostmans River in the Florida Everglades | Tampa Bay Times St. Petersburg Times St. Petersburg, Florida · Monday, February 01, 1932 |
| BURIAL: Everglades, Florida. No body found. | Assumed |
FLORIDA KEYS HISTORY FACEBOOK GROUP: Consider joining our group for more on Florida Keys History.
FLORIDA EVERGLADES HISTORY FACEBOOK GROUP: Consider joining our group for more on Florida Everglades History.

