by Karen Yvonne Hamilton, 2024. UPDATED October 2026

BIRTH

Mary Elizabeth Hamilton was born on October 15, 1888 to Richard HAMILTON (1840-1944) and Mary Appolonia WEEKS (1859-1917).



SIBLINGS

*It is unclear if Nina was Richard’s child or the child of Mary’s first husband, George CHRISTIAN.

In June 1900, the census placed Mary Elizabeth in her parents’ household at Chokoloskee, then part of Monroe County. Richard was recorded as a farmer, while older sons contributed work as farm laborers. Mary occupied a place between older brothers and younger sisters in a household whose livelihood depended on the work of its members.

1st MARRIAGE


Mary’s childhood was followed by an exceptionally early marriage. Her first husband was Henry Short and places their marriage in Key West in 1901. Their marriage license lists the wedding taking place on June 4. Mary was just a few months shy of 13 years old.

The surviving material does not explain the circumstances of that marriage or how long Mary and Henry lived together. No divorce record has been located in the research supplied. Henry was identified as divorced in the 1920 census, but that later entry does not establish when or how their marriage ended.

Family tradition connects Henry Short with the men who killed Edgar J. Watson at Chokoloskee’s Smallwood Store in 1910. Family lore claims that Henry may have fired the fatal shot. That account remains unverified, and it cannot tell us what Mary herself knew or experienced.

The true story of the Hamilton family in Peter Matthiessen’s book, Killing Mr. Watson

Henry Short (not verified)

Henry Short was born about January 1869. Parentage unknown at this known. His birth date is inferred here from the only two documents I have found on him as of this date.

Florida Passenger Lists, 1898-1964. Arrival May 1 1931 in Key West from Ft Myers aboard the S. S. Governor Cobb.
1920 United States Federal Census. Monroe County, Flamingo. Divorced boarder in the household of Erskin and Annie Rolle.

2nd MARRIAGE

A more sustained record of Mary’s adult life begins with her marriage to John Franklin Johnson on October 26, 1907, in Lee County. Shortly after her nineteenth birthday, she entered the marriage that would shape the next five decades of her life.

John Franklin JOHNSON, Mary HAMILTON Johnson, and Roy ACUFF

CHILDREN

John Franklin Johnson 1882–1957

Elmer Frank Johnson 1908–1996

Elizabeth R. Johnson 1911–1995

Bessie Johnson 1912–1998

Mary Anna Johnson 1914–1921

John F. Johnson 1924–1989

Eugene Roland Johnson 1927–1981

Marion Johnson abt 1932–1998


By 1910, Mary and John were living in Estero. The census recorded John as a mail carrier, providing a glimpse of his working life before later records identified him with fishing. Their family history lists seven children: Elmer Frank, Elizabeth R., Bessie, Mary Anna, John F., Eugene Roland, and Marion.

The children’s births extended across many years. Elmer was born in 1908, followed by Elizabeth in 1911, Bessie in 1912, and Mary Anna in 1914. During these years, Mary also lost her mother, Mary Appolonia, who died in 1917.


In 1920, the Johnson household stood near the mouth of Spring Creek in the Bonita Springs area. John was recorded as a fisherman working from his own boat. Elmer, Elizabeth, Bessie, and Mary Anna were listed with their parents. The census places the family within a community where fishing supported neighboring households as well as their own.

The following year brought the death of Mary Anna. The family biography gives her life dates as 1914–1921. She was about seven years old. The supplied records do not establish the cause of her death, leaving a painful absence in the family’s chronology without an explanation of its circumstances.

The household continued to grow. John F. was born in 1924 and Eugene Roland in 1927.


By 1930, the family was living on Big Hickory Island. John remained a fisherman, and the census recorded that the family owned its home. Mary’s life was still closely tied to the coastal waters, even as the children grew and the composition of the household changed.


The 1935 Florida census again placed the Johnsons in the Estero area.


Five years later, in 1940, the federal census located them on rural Estero Island. John continued fishing, while Mary was recorded with sons John, Eugene, and Marion.


DEATH

John Franklin Johnson died in 1957. Mary survived him by approximately eleven years, living long enough to see the children of their early married life reach middle age.

Mary Elizabeth died in Fort Myers, Lee County, on January 15, 1968, at seventy-nine. She was buried in North Naples, Collier County.

NOTE: If anyone has photos of Mary Hamilton, please share. Thank you.

SOURCES

ANCESTRY WORKSHEET last updated October 15, 2026 by Karen Yvonne Hamilton

BIOGRAPHY LINK: https://exploringfloridahistory.org/2024/12/18/mary-elizabeth-hamilton/ 

     Supporting Document
Mary Elizabeth Hamilton     
Father: Richard Edward HAMILTONCensus records; family lore
Mother: Mary Appolonia WEEKSCensus records; family lore
Birth: 15 Oct 1888  U.S., Social Security Death Index, 1935-2014
MARRIAGE: Henry Short, 4 June 1901Marriage License State of Florida, Monroe County. No record of divorce found.
MARRIAGE: John Franklin Johnson, 26 Oct 1907, Lee, FloridaFlorida, County Marriage Records, 1823-1982; U.S., Social Security Applications and Claims Index, 1936-2007; Census records
CHILDREN: John Franklin Johnson 1882–1957; Elmer Frank Johnson 1908–1996; Elizabeth R. Johnson 1911–1995; Bessie Johnson 1912–1998; Mary Anna Johnson 1914–1921; John F. Johnson 1924–1989; Eugene Roland Johnson 1927–1981; Marion Johnson abt. 1932–1998Census records; family lore; U.S., Social Security Applications and Claims Index, 1936-2007 (Marion)
Residences
(1900) Chokoloskee, Monroe, Florida1900 United States Federal Census
(1910) Estero, Lee, Florida1910 United States Federal Census
(1920) Bonita Springs, Lee, Florida, Near Mouth of Spring Creek1920 United States Federal Census
(1930) 18 Big Hickory Isla, Bonita Springs, Lee, Florida1930 United States Federal Census
(1935) Estero, Lee, Florida1935 Special United States Federal Census. Precinct 22 Lee County Page 4 Line 16 Archive Series #S5, Roll 18
(1940) Rural Estero Island, Lee, Florida1940 United States Federal Census
Death Date:  15 Jan 1968, Fort Myers, Lee County, FloridaU.S., Social Security Death Index, 1935-2014; U.S., Social Security Applications and Claims Index, 1936-2007; Florida Death Index, 1877-1998; https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/16892243/mary-elizabeth-johnson
Burial: North Naples, Collier County, Floridahttps://www.findagrave.com/memorial/16892243/mary-elizabeth-johnson

=======================================================================================

FLORIDA KEYS HISTORY FACEBOOK GROUP: Consider joining our group for more on Florida Keys History.

FLORIDA EVERGLADES HISTORY FACEBOOK GROUP: Consider joining our group for more on Florida Everglades History.